Have any of you tried with professional voice training, singing leassons or anything like that. 你们有谁尝试过专业的嗓音训练,唱歌练习或是其他的吗?
Dont you think it may be a way to strengthen the throat and avoid squeaky voices and other bulbar symptoms? 你们认为这是个加强喉咙肌肉,避免鼻音和其他延髓症状的方法吗?
Also may be it will improve breathing and help with some of the "slimy" throat symptoms? 可能这会提高呼吸能力,帮忙克服某些粘滑喉咙症状?
I am ceriously considering to try. 可我正在考虑来尝试一下
I really cant sing and have a bit trouble overcoming my shyness.我不擅长唱歌,而且克服我的害羞有点困难
Does singing help? I realise that MG does not improve the sound of it :) 唱歌能有帮助吗?我觉得患MG一点也不会提高唱歌的声音.
chairman MGA Chairman 650 post s 3-Jan-2008 2:25 AM
Hellemo
I speak as someone who does not have MG, but I have had voice training, and solo and choral singing are two of my main hobbies. 我作为一个非MG人士发言.我有过声音训练,独声和合唱是我的两大爱好.
Also my daughter, who does have MG, has continued with her singing activities while taking medication for MG. 而且我女儿,患MG,在她吃药的同时也坚持唱歌.
HOWEVER - as with any activity which uses muscles affected by MG, singing cannot help to strengthen those muscles unless the underlying cause of the weakness is first treated . 然而,和其他任何需要使用MG影响过的肌肉的活动一样.唱歌不能帮助加强肌肉,除非这些导致力弱的情况被解决.
SO - first get the MG under control - then take as much physical exercise as you can tolerate (including singing).所以先把MG控制好,然后再尽可能的来进行身体方面可能承受的练习包括唱歌. ----------
I mean, learning how to breathe better, and getting a better understanding of how the voice works. Getting to know how best to use the muscles affected.
I do gp to a mensendieck gymnastic-therapist and that has helped a lot with the rest of my body. It really does make a difference that I now know how things are suposed to work, how to correct bad posture and avoid pain that come from bad posture. I Thougt that may be something similiar could be achieved with my bulbar problems.
重症肌无力病友之家 → 老外也无力 → 唱歌能帮助提高发音吗
Peter Finney
发表时间：2008-01-08 11:16:01 
IP：
尝试过，自认为还是有效果的；